TYVM I'm sure this will help me alot, on my road to becoming MT.

Hey why is this not stickyed anymore? Just because Ciderhelm is leaveing the game you guys got to screw the warrior community by unstickying his uber post?

---

Q u o t e:


That doesn't harm the usefulness of this resource. This information is still current and accurate. If there is a patch that changes something then we can talk but even then it'd have to be a significant change as this guide is very comprehensive.

---

Yeah, but the problem is that only the original poster can update it, and if that person is gone, the information will be dated sooner or later. It's kind of draconian of the mods, yes, and I'm surprised at the swiftness of the response (it goes to show they do in fact monitor our community... Cider's post gets unsticked a few days after he announces he's leaving? I don't believe in coincidence), but I do understand where they are coming from. I immedietly copied and pasted the full text of the guide when I saw Cider was leaving because I figured the unsticky was coming

---

Q u o t e:


Yeah, but the problem is that only the original poster can update it, and if that person is gone, the information will be dated sooner or later. It's kind of draconian of the mods, yes, and I'm surprised at the swiftness of the response (it goes to show they do in fact monitor our community... Cider's post gets unsticked a few days after he announces he's leaving? I don't believe in coincidence), but I do understand where they are coming from. I immedietly copied and pasted the full text of the guide when I saw Cider was leaving because I figured the unsticky was coming

---

I also copyed the post to my Microsoft Word. AS for your point. Ya it cant be updated but damn wait for the next big patch to come out before you unsticky good valid information.

---

Q u o t e:


Yeah, but the problem is that only the original poster can update it, and if that person is gone, the information will be dated sooner or later. It's kind of draconian of the mods, yes, and I'm surprised at the swiftness of the response (it goes to show they do in fact monitor our community... Cider's post gets unsticked a few days after he announces he's leaving? I don't believe in coincidence), but I do understand where they are coming from. I immedietly copied and pasted the full text of the guide when I saw Cider was leaving because I figured the unsticky was coming

---

your logic is sound - but the premise is incorrect... they also unstuck many others...

/taunt Blue

Ah, I didn't even notice the DW Fury Gear list got dropped as well.

Ya know, one of the thing I miss mosts about Everquest is that each class usually had an independant of the game company site where alot of folks congregated to discuss the class. Too bad that hasn't happened for this game.

why have all these been unstuck?

how is this not stickied

Ciderhelm, I salute you. You and your guide really stand out as a Tank amongst warriors. You have renewed my intrest in Protection Spec. Thank You.

/salute

Bump since it fell off

---

Q u o t e:
Can we get a sticky on this post again, please.

---

Hear hear.

---

Q u o t e:
Ah, I didn't even notice the DW Fury Gear list got dropped as well.

---

That one never was stickied. Pretty sure I would have noticed.

/bump sticky request put in again...

Seriously, in the interest of benefitting every single intelligent person out there who plays a warrior.. please please please re-sticky this. This if anything is what these forums need.

if you fail to see its relivance, outdated or not.... reroll.

BUMP FOR STICKY

Why isn't this stickied yet?

Cider- I have 2 questions that you did not answer in your original post:

If an ability crits- how is the threat factored?
Ex: Shield Slam crits for 1000 (2x the normal amount)
the formula is threat = (innate threat value) + (dmg component)
but in the event of a crit, does the total threat jump by a factor of 2, or just the dmg component?

You listed the main aggro-producing abilities and their values. My question pertains to an unorthodox tanking rage dump - being Bloodthirst. The up-front value of damage directly represents the threat produced, but are the following heals threat-free or incur the usual 1/2 value from healing?

---

Q u o t e:
Cider- I have 2 questions that you did not answer in your original post:

If an ability crits- how is the threat factored?
Ex: Shield Slam crits for 1000 (2x the normal amount)
the formula is threat = (innate threat value) + (dmg component)
but in the event of a crit, does the total threat jump by a factor of 2, or just the dmg component?

You listed the main aggro-producing abilities and their values. My question pertains to an unorthodox tanking rage dump - being Bloodthirst. The up-front value of damage directly represents the threat produced, but are the following heals threat-free or incur the usual 1/2 value from healing?

---

Let C = 2 <---- crit multiplier, replace with 2.2 or other value if a yellow attack talented with impale

The damage-based component of the threat from an ability is multiplied by C in the case of a crit.

BUMP? SSSSTTTTTIIIIIICCCCCC@*!KKYYYYYYY?

---

Q u o t e:


Let C = 2 <---- crit multiplier, replace with 2.2 or other value if a yellow attack talented with impale

The damage-based component of the threat from an ability is multiplied by C in the case of a crit.

BUMP? SSSSTTTTTIIIIIICCCCCC@*!KKYYYYYYY?

---

I think having three letter k's in sequence must be disallowed.